Gabungan Pilihanraya Bersih dan Adil / Coalition for Clean and Fair Elections

‘No local elections’: Gerakan, Pakatan tick off PM

March 9th, 2010 | Posted in Media Coverage | No Comments » | Print This Post Print This Post

Yip Ai Tsin (Malaysiakini)

Prime Minister Najib Abdul Razak’s statement today that it was unnecessary to hold local government elections has brought a howl of protest from inside and outside the BN coalition.

In an immediate reaction, Kedah Gerakan Youth chief Tan Keng Liang said while he understands the premier’s concern that such elections would lead to too much ‘politicking’, the “advantages of local government elections outweigh its rejection”.

Tan also urged the federal government to assist the Pakatan states to hold the local government elections, including making amendments to the relevant laws to allow states that opt for local government elections to do so.

BN kills democracy in school. No elections only appointment by HMs…Schools no freedom of choice.

March 9th, 2010 | Posted in Commentary/Blog Post | No Comments » | Print This Post Print This Post

BN kills democracy in school. No elections only appointment by HMs…Schools no freedom of choice.
Democracy is something that must be promoted. The culture and value of democracy must be cultivated from young.

People choose their own leaders/representat ives
- NOT the government choose and appoint the leaders
- NOT the Teacher choose and appoint the student leaders..prefects. .etc

Now the UMNO-led BN Government has ordered all schools – and told them to do away with ’students’ participation’ in the election of prefects? [Does this also apply to school societies, uniform bodies, sports teams - no more democracy, teacher-in-charge choose and appoint the leaders???]

GEORGE TOWN: Schools must stop conducting elections to choose prefects because such appointments are the prerogative of the principals.

State education director Ibrahim Mohamad said the directive came from the Education Ministry.
“I want to inform all schools to stop such practices. There is no need for an election for prefects.

“Headmasters and principals should appoint suitable candidates,” he told school heads during a Chinese New Year luncheon at the education department yesterday.

On Feb 12, some 2,000 students of SMK Raja Tun Uda in Bayan Baru experienced an election atmosphere when the school carried out its election for prefects over two days.

A total of 56 candidates from Form 1 to Form 4 stood for the election.

It was held with the help from the Penang Elections Commission.

SMK Raja Tun Uda is the only school in the state to have carried out such an election.

On a separate matter, Ibrahim urged schools to be prudent in managing their finances but that training for teachers must go on.

“Schools must continue conducting training courses for teachers – we are waiting for funding from the ministry and once we receive it, we will disburse it to the various schools.

“Meanwhile, you must not use that as an excuse not to train teachers,” he said, admitting that he was unsure if the federal training allocation of RM200 per teacher would be available this year.- Star, 26/2/2010, ‘No’ to prefect polls, appointments by principals

FREEDOM – schools, headmasters, teachers should have the freedom to conduct elections or not – why is the government depriving them of choice, freedom…?

DEMOCRACY – this culture and practice must be inculcated from a young age. Students should be allowed to choose their own leaders..

***But, then they are talking about school prefects – and these really are not the leaders of students, but merely the ’school police personnel’, who serve the headmaster/teachers in ensuring that all the other students follow the ‘laws’ …and catch them when they do not. Prefects are agents of HMs/teachers – and are really ‘anti-students’ .

But, in Malaysia, we do not have true democracy because the government still chooses and appoint community leaders (be it the Ketua Kampungs/Kampung Baru/Taman Perumahan/Kampung Orang Asli, JKKKK, JKKKT, Local Councillors or even Pakatan’s Majlis Perwakilan Penduduk]

This kind of practice happens in a dictatorship, authoritarian regime, feudal society ….but certainly not in a democracy.

GOVERNTMENT SAYS YO THE PEOPLE
Oh people! You are ‘immature’.. .stupid – incapable in chosing your own local leaders, so “WE” will choose them for you. You just listen and accept. Do not protest. WE know what is best. You have no CHOICE in the matter.

When Pakatan Rakyat also behaves in the same manner like the BN when it comes to the question of ‘true democracy” – then the people really have not much of a choice, do they?

Local elections: S’gor to follow Penang

March 9th, 2010 | Posted in Notice Board | No Comments » | Print This Post Print This Post

Aidila Razak (Malaysiakini)

Selangor today came out in support of the Penang government’s move towards reinstating local government elections.

selangor pakatan convention khalid ibrahim speech“We will write a letter to the Election Commission (EC) alongside the Penang government (which did so yesterday) to find out what kind of support the commission will give us for such elections,” Selangor Menteri Besar Abdul Khalid Ibrahim told a press conference after the officiating the Selangor Pakatan convention this morning in Shah Alam.

PM: Local gov’t polls unnecessary

March 9th, 2010 | Posted in Media Coverage | No Comments » | Print This Post Print This Post

Malaysiakini

Prime Minister Najib Abdul Razak said it was unnecessary to hold local government elections as it would cause too much politicking.

He said this today in Putrajaya in response to demands by the Pakatan Rakyat held state governments of Penang and Selangor to hold local polls.

On Saturday, Penang Chief Minister Lim Guan Eng said his government wanted to restore elections in two municipal councils and he had written a letter to the Election Commission.

Putrajaya not keen to restore third vote

March 9th, 2010 | Posted in Media Coverage | No Comments » | Print This Post Print This Post

By Adib Zalkapli (Malaysian Insider)

PUTRAJAYA, March 9 — The Federal government is not interested to restore local council elections as it will not necessarily improve public services, said Datuk Seri Najib Razak.

The Prime Minister was responding to the move by the Selangor and Penang governments to get the Election Commission (EC) to conduct local government elections in the two states.

“We are of the opinion that the local government elections were abolished long time ago, so there is no need to restore it,” said Najib.

Local government elections were first held in 1951 before Merdeka but abolished in 1965 during the Confrontation with Indonesia.

The then Prime Minister Tunku Abdul Rahman promised it would be restored after the situation improved.

Make way for local elections

March 9th, 2010 | Posted in Commentary/Blog Post | No Comments » | Print This Post Print This Post

Malaysian Insider

MARCH 9 — What a wonderful piece of news. That aptly describes my reaction upon learning the request of the Penang state government to the Election Commission to organize two local elections in the Pearl of the Orient this year.

Selangor’s decision to follow suit makes it an all the more brilliant development.

There are obstacles to overcome and there is no guarantee that the return will happen for good.

There will be challenges no doubt. The EC is already showing sign of reluctance to do as requested.

It is quite clear that not everybody is convinced of the necessity of local elections. Some fear losing their power. Others are caught up in legalese.

Let them lose their powers. It is not theirs to keep in the first place. Be gone with the legalese. We are in a new time where old threats have long past.

The actual push for it in Malaysia is long overdue. This right of ours has been robbed from us. It is only right to have it returned.

What I am most excited about the prospect of having local elections returned is the devolution of power. It is yet another tool to empower citizens at the expense of the state. For too long has power been concentrated in the hand of the state.

The return of the third vote will chip away that focused power by distributing it more evenly across the landscape, as it should have been.

Do you remember how such power distribution felt?

The last time such significant redistribution happened was in March 2008.

Yes, it has been two years since that day. Since then, there have been many disappointments: the lies and hypocrisy regarding freedom of association, more slogans, disloyalty and generally broken promises.

Yes, many of these disappointments have began to question the wisdom of many whom gave members or former members of what is now Pakatan Rakyat a chance.

That in no way changes the fact that the 2008 Malaysian general election demonstrated that individual citizens do have the power to change the course of the country.

It is a reminder that the kind of confidence in individuals that seemed to exist only in Ayn Rand’s Atlas Shrugged does exist in the real world. It blew away the feeling of helplessness that nothing can be done.

It proves that in the face of a titan, individuals can be as fearsome as the titan can.

My feeling as a first time voter in the early morning of March 9 was one of pure exhilaration.

After all the disillusionment, the feeling that this country belonged only to the selected few forming a cabal, the election showed that I still do have stake in the country. More importantly, I can act on that ownership.

The devolution will further prove that I, along with many other Malaysians, do have ownership over not just the country, but also the street where I — we — live in. We are the ones that should take care of our own streets.

We pay for it after all.

With the third vote, we can stop pretending that those representatives we send to national and state assemblies are taking care of our local interests.

We do not need an MP or state assemblypersons to take care of our streets and everything else in our immediate neighborhood.

We can do it ourselves.

Such absurd pretentions have caused Members of Parliament and state assemblies having to deal with local problems while they are supposed to debate on nation and statewide issues respectively.

It is not the jobs of these representatives to worry about sewage and trash. Those are the responsibilities of local councilors.

Local elections will enhance the division of tasks and with the division of tasks comes the division of power.

Less power in the hand of the few means less opportunity for abuse.

If this is what those who oppose the reintroduction fear, then let them fear it.

*Hafiz Noor Shams is a fellow at the Institute for Democracy and Economic Affairs (IDEAS).

Restoration of Local Government Elections: Now for the Implementation…

March 8th, 2010 | Posted in Press Release | No Comments » | Print This Post Print This Post

SUARAM welcomes the announcement by both the Penang Chief Minister and the Selangor Menteri Besar that the respective state governments of Penang and Selangor have decided to restore local government elections and instructed the Elections Commission to conduct elections for local council governments in both states.

These announcements have come after a long wait since the last local elections were held in 1963. Elections at the local level have since been suspended under a proclamation of emergency in September 1964 during the Indonesia-staged Confrontation.

A New Chapter in Malaysian Democracy

SUARAM recognises that this move by the Penang and the Selangor state governments in announcing its decision to restore local government elections not only paves the way for a new chapter in Malaysian democracy, but also indicates the political will of the two state governments to fulfill its promises in last General Election – 2 years after coming to power in their respective states.

SUARAM stresses the importance of the restoration of local government elections as it would reinstate the people’s right to elect their representatives who will deal with their local issues. It would also mark a return of the fundamental principle of “no taxation without representation” and ensure a more direct participation of the people in the decision making process at the local level.

All Appointed Councillors Should Vacate Their Positions

While welcoming the decision of the Penang and Selangor state governments, SUARAM urges all appointed Councillors in the two states to vacate their respective current positions in order to expedite and pave way for the elections of new Councillors there, as well as to demonstrate the seriousness of the Penang and Selangor state governments in their efforts.

All Other State Governments Should Follow Suit

SUARAM further urges all other state governments – both in Pakatan Rakyat- and Barisan Nasional-ruled states – to also make the same call as that have been made by the state governments of Penang and Selangor.

SUARAM also calls on the federal government to implement local council elections at the Federal Territories and hold direct elections for the position of the Mayor.

Amend All Relevant Laws Immediately!

To ensure the smooth implementation of the local council elections, SUARAM calls on the Barisan Nasional federal government to initiate amendments to all relevant laws on local government in the coming Parliamentary sitting. By doing so, any existing legal obstacles which may impede the restoration of local council elections will be overcome and as such, the Elections Commission would thus be able focus its efforts solely on technical matters pertaining to the implementation of elections at the local government level.

Lastly, SUARAM looks forward to the implementation of local council elections nationwide in the near future.

Make Democracy the only game in town

March 8th, 2010 | Posted in Press Release | No Comments » | Print This Post Print This Post

Civil Society Joint Statement on the 2nd Anniversary of March 8 2008 General Elections

Two years ago, Malaysians wrote history by weakening UMNO/Barisan Nasional’s electoral one-party state. For the first time since independence, the ruling coalition lost its two-third parliamentary majority and a total of five states were ruled by the opposition parties.

As a result, Malaysians has benefited tremendously from vibrant competition between Barisan Nasional and Pakatan Rakyat. As Pakatan Rakyat advocate “Ketuanan Rakyat” and values like competence, accountability and transparency, Barisan Nasional under Prime Minister Najib Razak respond with his “1Malaysia” campaign and “Government Transformation Programme”. In brief, Malaysians are enjoying the bonus of democratization.

Unfortunately, the budding democratisation is also threatened by politicians who refuse to accept “democracy as the only game in town” and try to subvert the voters’ verdict through at least three unscrupulous means: (a) defection and change of government without fresh elections; (b) politically-motivated investigation, prosecution, harassment and detention of opposition leaders, civil society activists, journalists and bloggers; (c) discrimination in development funding against opposition-run state governments and opposition-won constituencies.

These undemocratic acts disrupt our public life and threaten political stability. The latest defection and quitting of PKR lawmakers are both a betrayal to their voters and an assault to Malaysia’s party system. Malaysia would be in a total chaos and even induce coups if popular mandate can be ignored and violated at whim.

On the 2nd anniversary of March 8 election, we the undersigned civil society groups call upon all political parties to respect the voters’ verdict made on March 8 2008. We urge them to promise the following five basic reforms in their present or future capacity as federal and state governments.

1. That Article 48(6) of the Federal Constitution and similar provisions in state constitutions be amended to allow elected representatives resign and re-contest when they disagree with their party.

2. That “recall elections” be introduced so that voters may sack elected representatives who underperform or betray their mandate.

3. That the Federal Government would respect the spirit of federalism and threat all state governments and members of parliament fairly regardless of party affiliation in term of grants, subsidies, royalties, etc.

4. That the State Governments would threat all state assemblypersons fairly regardless of party affiliation in term of allowance and support; and also hold local elections so that all parties may have the chance to win representation in local governments.

5. That all anti-human rights legislations be repealed and all politically-motivated investigation and prosecution be stopped immediately.

We also call upon all Malaysians to pursue these demands with both Barisan Nasional and Pakatan Rakyat. We must defend the fruit of March 8 and defeat all attempts to roll back the democratisation process. Come next elections, let us decide our votes based on the coalitions’ fulfilment of these demands.

Let us reclaim our country and make democracy the only game in town.

Pakatan states could follow Penang in third vote bid

March 8th, 2010 | Posted in Media Coverage | No Comments » | Print This Post Print This Post

Malaysian Insider
By Clara Choo

KUALA LUMPUR, March 8 — All Pakatan Rakyat-ruled states might emulate the Penang government to seek restoring local government elections, once the Election Commission (EC) decides on the matter.

Already, the Selangor government has joined Penang in the bid with Mentri Besar Tan Sri Khalid Ibrahim confirming the state government would write to the EC to hold the third vote.

Pakatan leader Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim said today that the restoration of local council elections, a proposal that DAP secretary-general and Penang Chief Minister Lim Guan Eng has been pushing since 2007, had already been given an approval in principle by the coalition.

He carefully said however that the other parties would first wait to see how the issue panned out with Penang before making a blanket decision for the remaining Pakatan states.

Aside from Penang and Selangor, the states of Kedah and Kelantan are also run by Pakatan.

“We have already agreed on this, as approved during the (Pakatan Rakyat) convention (last year) that we will look at the details, the provisions in the law. So I think once the EC gives its answer, we (Pakatan leadership) will meet and we will see then how to move on,” he said.

PAS vice-president Salahuddin Ayub agreed, and said the Pakatan parties are now simply trying to identify the best mechanism on restoring the elections.

The Pakatan component parties of PKR, DAP and PAS campaigned during Election 2008 with promises of local government elections.

Lim had pushed for it in the Common Policy Framework of the Pakatan Rakyat unveiled last December, but the coalition pact opted to go for the phrase “strengthening local government democracy”.

Meanwhile, the Penang government is appealing to the EC to hold a discussion first before making a decision on holding the elections.

Lim said that the state government is ready to discuss how to fine-tune the details so that the commission could better understand the issue.

“We want them to make a decision only after having a discussion with us for otherwise, it may seem as if they are taking directions from certain quarters,” he said.

The Penang government, following a state executive council meeting, had sent a letter to the EC on March 4, asking the commission to hold local government elections for the Penang Municipal Council and the Seberang Prai Municipal Council.

The state was invoking its powers under Article 113(4) of the Federal Constitution, which states that federal or state law may authorise the EC to conduct elections other than parliamentary or state elections.

However EC chairman Tan Sri Abdul Aziz Mohd Yusof has admitted that the body had no experience in conducting such polls.

“If we follow the process in the early 1960s, the elections were conducted by the EC. They are the competent authority to hold these elections. Since Penang is definitely the first state in history to exercise Article 113(4) however, maybe the EC is not used to it or is unaware on the procedures involved in conducting local government elections.

“However, we are ready to discuss this with them first. We hope they will discuss it before deciding,” said Lim.

Federal Government Must Match the Call to Bring Back Local Council Elections

March 7th, 2010 | Posted in Press Release | No Comments » | Print This Post Print This Post

The Coalition for Good Governance (CGG) applauds the Penang and the Selangor State Governments for their political maturity in responding to the peoples’ call to bring back local council elections.

CGG hopes that other state governments will also follow suit and take the brave step to bring back local council elections and restore mechanisms for local democracy.

However, we would also like to remind the Penang Chief Minister and Selangor Menteri Besar that in the event that the Election Commission refuses to co-operate with the Penang and the Selangor State Governments on the basis that it is of the view that there is still a need to amend Federal laws, CGG proposes that state governments instead conduct a People-Oriented Selection Process (POSP).

CGG has conducted a research for the Selangor state government and gave three options on how local council elections can be carried out. CGG proposes to state governments to conduct a People-Oriented Selection Process (POSP). This POSP will by-pass the Election Commission and still give due recognition to the elected candidates. The POSP will run like an election, whereby candidates are “nominated” by communities at their constituency levels. Once nominated, the state government will name and appoint these nominees as the rightful councillors for the specified constituency. This method can be carried out at the shortest possible time frame – within 12 months. The POSP will enable citizens to reclaim their rights to the third vote.

As part of the Prime Minister’s call, “People First, Performance Now”, CGG strongly urges the Federal Government to match this promise made to the people and restore local council elections, as it was the Federal Government that abolished local elections in 1965. Prime Minister Najib Tun Razak and his administration must be held responsible to take the lead to ensure that the Election Commission assists in the administration of the local council elections in Penang and Selangor and ensure a free and fair elections.

CGG, as a coalition committed to local democracy, has started its campaign, People’s participation, Right to Information and Local Council Elections (PIE campaign). The PIE campaign is to create new politics where citizens positively engage in a dynamic, relevant and vibrant local democracy. Participating in local democracy is an efficient, effective way of influencing what happens to the people. This campaign is a Rakyat’s call for more efforts to be put into place to increase people’s participation, to enact a Right to Information Act and also to bring back local council elections.

CGG, therefore, calls upon the Federal government to rise to the occasion to improve accountability, transparency and to bring back justice to the citizens. Bringing back local council elections will be the litmus test to the principles of accountability, openness and transparency in all governments.